Cloud Storage vs NAS Cost Calculator

Paying for cloud storage every month, or buying a NAS once and running it yourself? This calculator puts both on the same timeline. Enter how much data you have, a cloud price, and what the NAS and drives cost you, and it shows the month the NAS breaks even and the 3-year and 5-year totals for each.

The preset cloud prices are examples taken from the providers’ public US pricing pages on November 20, 2026. Prices change and differ by country and tax, so check the provider’s page and type in what you would actually pay.

Upfront and drive costs are your own numbers: enter what you paid or were quoted. The defaults are placeholders, not prices for any product.

NAS breaks even–
Cloud per month–
NAS running per month–
  • Cloud, 3-year total–
  • NAS, 3-year total–
  • Cloud, 5-year total–
  • NAS, 5-year total–
  • NAS electricity–
  • Drive replacements counted–

How this is calculated

  • Cloud cost per month = price per TB × TB stored, or the flat plan price (times the number of plans needed if your data is bigger than one plan).
  • NAS running cost per month = watts × 24 hours × 30.4 days ÷ 1,000 × your electricity rate, plus any off-site backup you pay for.
  • NAS total after a number of months = upfront cost + running cost × months + the drive cost each time a replacement falls due. A 5-year replacement is counted at the start of year 6, so it shows up after the 5-year total.
  • Break-even is the first month where the NAS running total is equal to or lower than the cloud running total. The calculator checks the first 10 years.

What the numbers leave out

  • A NAS is not a backup on its own. If the NAS holds the only copy of your data, a fire, theft or failed rebuild can take everything. The 3-2-1 rule calls for an off-site copy, which is what the off-site backup field is for.
  • Usable vs raw space. Mirrored or RAID 5/6 arrays give you less space than the raw drive total. Use the RAID capacity calculator to check the drives you are pricing actually hold your data.
  • Data growth and price changes. The calculator assumes your data and the cloud price stay the same. If you add a lot each year, the cloud side grows every month while the NAS only costs more when you add drives.
  • Download and restore fees, your time, and resale value are not included.

Related: 3-2-1 backup strategy for a home lab · Best NAS for first-time builders · Best NAS hard drives · Home lab electricity cost calculator

For general informational purposes only; not professional advice. Posts may contain affiliate links. Learn more.
Scroll to Top